There has been a lot of outcry in the social media lately
about whether a corporation is or isn’t a person. It seems to me that someone
has taken something out of context and used it to lash people who do not know
the law into a frenzy. So here’s the scoop, folks. And why should you believe
what I say? Because I am a business law attorney. This is what I do, and have
done for more than 10 years.
OK, so. Let’s talk about forms of business. When a natural
person starts a business, it’s usually a sole proprietorship, which simply
means a business with one individual owner. Under the law, there is no
difference between the business owner’s personal life and their business life. The
owner’s business assets can be seized to pay the owner’s personal debts, and
more importantly, the owner’s personal assets can be seized to pay the business’s
debts.
So how does an individual protect his personal assets (i.e.,
his house, his car, his children’s toys, and the cash he uses to feed his
children) from business liabilities? He (or she) forms a corporation. The corporation
is what we lawyer-types call a legal fiction – it is an entity separate from
its owner. It pays its own taxes, nearly always at a higher marginal rate than
the owner’s personal rate. It buys and sells property in its own name. It can
sue and be sued in its own name. Why? Because the legal definition of “person”
includes corporations. If a corporation
was not a “person” under the law, there could be no way to protect the business
owner’s personal assets from something horrible that happened in his business.
Let’s take a common occurrence as an illustration. A decides
that she has a product that the world desperately needs. Her market research
shows a need, so she starts making and marketing the product. A million units
later, the manufacturing process hiccups and a single unit explodes, injuring
Customer’s child. Customer sues A for damages done to the child.
If A is a sole proprietor, depending on the state where she
lives, she could lose EVERYTHING. She could lose her house, her car, her
business (remember, this is how she supports her family). Her family could be
homeless, and now her children don’t have a place to live.
If, however, A formed a corporation, Customer would sue the
corporation. A’s personal property would be protected and her children would be
OK. The corporation may be out of business, but A and her family are still on
her feet.
Do you begin to see why it is important that a corporation
be a “person” under the law? It all has to do with protecting the owner.
Besides all that, who is a corporation, really? It’s people.
The shareholders are people. The directors and officers are people.
Corporations aren’t faceless. They are operated by people. Those people are
generally decent, just like you. Sure, there are a few bad apples. There are in
ANY group – of people.
So don’t buy in to the falsehood that corporations shouldn’t
be people under the law. If we did away with that very basic point of American
law, many more individuals would be bankrupt and out on the streets.
Corporations are the backbone of American business – I’m not talking about
megacorporations; I’m talking about the small Mom & Pop corporations that
are formed every day. Be aware. Be informed. And for all our sakes, don’t just
fall into lockstep with any political party’s agenda.
No comments:
Post a Comment